A Resource of the Asia Society
Asia Source
Arts and CultureBusiness and EconomicsPolicy and GovernmentSocial Issues

The Asia Society Guide to
Health and Education NGOs in India

Health NGOs in India

Government Resources, Medical Development and Defense Spending
While Indian law dictates that every citizen has a right to medical care, on a practical level the medical infrastructure cannot handle the vast population in need of care. Government hospitals in major urban areas are generally overbooked or substandard, while rural residents may go without any hospital service at all. On a national level, the Indian government spends only 1.3% of the gross domestic product on healthcare, while doling out 2.7% on military spending. This classic debate over defense spending or development is commonly known as the "guns vs. butter" debate, as butter is a symbol of economic prosperity and well-fed citizens. Additionally, much of India's healthcare budget depends on foreign aid to run and yet increases in size and scope of the military constantly threatens to curtail this foreign aid. For example, many donor nations are just now beginning to reinvest in humanitarian aid to India after the 1998 nuclear tests caused an international boycott of the country. Although many look to the government to improve infrastructure and implement healthcare, many more turn to NGOS to provide free clinics and emergency medical treatment. In the past few years, an increasing number of non-resident Indians, many of whom are doctors in counties abroad, have set up medical clinics in their home towns back in India. Meanwhile, many NGOs in India have been advocating a rollback of the arms race with Pakistan in favor of increased domestic spending on development. While the country has made many strides in the past few decades, India is still far from providing adequate healthcare to its citizens.

Articles and data

Ninth Five Year Plan
This is the Government of India's Ninth Five Year Plan for health and family welfare covering the period 1997--2002.

No fresh aid pledges for India
On May 25, 2000, the BBC reported that Indian officials and international donors met about poverty reduction and a restoration of international aid since the nuclear tests of 1998.

Economic Dimensions of Tests
This chapter, "Economic Dimensions of Tests," from the Asia Society publication South Asia After the Tests describes the effects of increased defense spending after the nuclear tests of 1998 on infrastructure.

India's Population Overwhelms its Health Care Capabilities
This report entitled, "India's Population Overwhelms its Health Care Capabilities" from Ocular Surgery News contextualizes health care spending within the governmental budget and the larger domestic infrastructure.


Editorials

Guns vs. Butter
Shashi Tharoor, executive assistant to the United Nations Secretary General, advocates infrastructure over defense in this column from the Indian Express.

Humane Development
Nobel Prize winning economist Amartya Sen has some unorthodox opinions on food supply, distribution of resources, and government spending, insisting that social scientists concentrate on the devastating effects of poverty and inequality. This interview with Sen from the Atlantic Monthly is a great introduction to Sen's views.






Women's Health
Like many areas of the world, the subject of women's health has been neglected in India. Cultural factors often dictate the maltreatment of girl children, with abortion and infanticide based on sex a significant factor in the female to male ratio. Once born, similar factors favor the medical and emotional wellbeing of boys at the expense of girl children, resulting in a higher rate of malnutrition and infectious diseases in girls. Girls born into poverty are especially at risk for malnutrition, and incur additional illness through hard labor and childbearing as adults. The concept of prenatal care is virtually nonexistent and many women do not visit the doctor or pay extra attention to nutritional intake while pregnant. On the national level, women's health is largely ignored, with an extraordinary amount of women living with little knowledge of birth control and reproductive health. In cases of extreme poverty, death by malnutrition or during childbirth are not unheard of. This is especially true in the north, where women in impoverished rural and urban areas have not yet reaped the benefits of improvements in infrastructure to the same extent as their southern counterparts. Additionally, in many parts of India domestic violence is a socially acceptable norm, with the cycle of abuse having a huge impact on the overall state of women's health. While dowry death and widow suicide are uncommon occurrences, they are extreme examples of how cultural attitudes towards women differentially influence life expectancy and health in female populations.

In the past thirty years, the establishment of more governmental health clinics have greatly improved women's access to healthcare. However, millions of women still lack basic medical treatment and information.

Articles and Information

Improving Women's Health in India
This basic overview of the status of women's health in India is from the World Bank report Improving Women's Health in India.

CRLP -- India
A great resource on women's health in India, this site from the Center on Reproductive Law and Policy focuses on government policy on women's health and reproductive rights.

Chronic Hunger and the Status of Women in India
This article from The Hunger Project details how malnutrition differentially targets the female body.


Views and Debates

Beijing + 5-year Review and Appraisal
This site, from the forum on women's health of the Bejing plus 5 Committee, hosts many postings about the status of Indian women from public health researchers, doctors and lay people.

Changing Concepts of Women's Health: Advocating for Change
In "Changing Concepts of Women's Health: Advocating for Change," the authors shed light on the changing definition of women's health, revealing how society's treatment of women affects their health. Not focused on South Asia, but a great resource nonetheless.

Organizations of Note

Moitree
Moitree, meaning "friendship" in Hindi, is a consortium of Indian women's organizations that deal with issues of women's health and domestic abuse.

HIV, prostitution, and sexual health
In a culture where sex is very rarely discussed, issues of sexual heath, prostitution, and sexually transmitted diseases (including HIV/AIDS) are often neglected by both governmental agencies and social activists. While the state of Tamil Nadu is noteworthy for its broad public health information initiatives to combat the spread of HIV, many state governments are contributing too little too late to control the disease. Prostitution in India is not limited to female sex workers and male clients; male homosexual prostitutes compromise a small but significant number of sex workers in large urban areas like Mumbai. Unfortunately, the issue of prostitution is inextricably linked to the spread of HIV/AIDS and the two issues must be dealt with in tandem, although the spread of HIV is clearly not limited to the prostitute/john relationship. The following brief introductions outline the problems of female and male health and the spread of HIV/AIDS in India.

Female Prostitution and HIV
Heterosexual prostitution is one of the main arenas in which HIV/AIDS is spread on the subcontinent, widely through women and girls who are forced into prostitution. Roughly 50% of female sex workers in Mumbai are HIV positive. Many of them are from Nepal, sold into prostitution by their families, and sent to work against their will in Indian brothels. The combined factors of poverty, misogyny, lack of education and poor healthcare add up to an alarming rate of HIV infection among Indian sex workers and women in general.

Recently, the Western media has paid a great deal of attention to the issue of prostitution and trafficking in India and many international women's groups have begun to do significant work on the issue. Along with this increased awareness, a number of questions and issues have arisen about the nature of prostitution in India and our international responsibility to help female prostitutes. Are sex workers helpless victims or agents of their own fate? Should our focus be to eliminate prostitution entirely or fight for the rights of sex workers? Would legalizing prostitution help or hurt the women involved? How do Indian images of female sexuality and the cultural legacies of courtesans and temple dancers inform the Indian sex trade? What role should international women's organizations play in helping female prostitutes in India?

Male sexual health and HIV
NGOs have shown remarkable success in mobilizing social groups overlooked by conventional institutions, including homosexuals and HIV/AIDS patients. According to Ashok Row Kavi of Humsafar Trust of India, the number of homosexual men and women in South Asia is approximately 50 million. Additionally, some surveys estimate that up to 30% of Indian men in certain areas have sexual relationships with men but do not consider themselves homosexuals. Yet the number of organizations designed to serve their interests is limited.

Crucial to the work of the Humsafar Trust is the recognition that patterns of HIV transmission in India are similar to those in the United States. While the World Health Organization and current conventional wisdom tracks the spread of HIV in the subcontinent primarily through heterosexual contact with female workers, the Trust asserts that male homosexual transmission is rampant yet undocumented.

Humsafar Trust has carried out informal surveys, and estimates from the responses that in India an alarming number of men who have sex with men are infected with HIV. Social mores and tightly knit family structures, along with traditions of dowry, create a situation where marriage is not only expected, but in fact is institutionalized and represents an economic income-generator for families of male children. As a result, sons who choose not to marry face enormous ostracism. For these reasons, many men who, given the choice, would rather not be married to a woman, enter into marriage for their family's sake but continue to have sex with other men. This scenario results in a subculture of men sexually active with each other yet maintaining an outward appearance of heterosexual family life. These are precisely the men the Trust would like to educate about HIV transmission. Barriers to carrying out such education projects are numerous, but perhaps the most important is the lack of an identified gay community to which the NGOs can direct its outreach efforts.

NGOs are working diligently to educate the public about the prevention of AIDS and provide support and counseling for HIV-infected persons. The additional dangers of placing value judgments on how individuals became HIV-positive is one of the toughest issues facing NGOs that work with people who are HIV positive. One key in the prevention of AIDS is to eliminate negative images of HIV-infected persons as projected by the media. NGOs should work toward educating the public to respect the dignity of all persons living with HIV, regardless of how they became infected.

The harm-reduction approach to prevent the spread and minimize the harmful effects of drug use is an increasingly popular and controversial method employed by NGOs. This approach involves distributing needles to drug users. Government and public officials have little understanding of these methods, and there is widespread opposition and reluctance on the part of donors to provide funds.

Articles and information

AIDS in Asia
This special report from AsiaSource on AIDS in Asia has great background information and links on the topic.

Health: HIV/AIDS Timebomb Ticking in India
For basic background information, see Laxmi Murthy's analysis from the OneWorld site.

HIV/AIDS around the world
A geographic analysis of HIV/AIDS infection on a global scale.

D3: Diet, Disease and Development in India and Indonesia
An in-depth public health research document on women and AIDS in India by W.C. Edmundson, P.V. Sukhatme and S.A. Edmundson.

The Politics of Life and Death: Global Responses to HIV AIDS
A personalized account of HIV, poverty, and drug treatment in India from Gay Today.


India Enlists Barbers in the War on AIDS
This article from the Wall Street Journal takes a look at governmental prevention programs in Tamil Nadu as a model for other states to emulate.

Separate AIDS Wards -- The Experience in Tamil Nadu
This article from US Aid India highlights Tamil Nadu's pioneering efforts in treating AIDS patients and suggests that separate AIDS wards have been more successful at treating the disease.

Debates


The Prostitution Questions(s) (Female ) Agency, Sexuality and Work
This article by Rajeshwari Sunder Rajan in Re/productions, a publication of the Harvard School of Public Health, provides a feminist analysis of prostitution in India.

Making the Harm Visible
This site hosts excerpts from Making the Harm Visible, a collection of essays on prostitution in international contexts from The Coalition Against Trafficking in Women.

Health-India: 2000 UN AIDS Theme Gender Biased, Say Women Activists
Women activists in India criticize the UN World AIDS campaign for being gender-biased against women.

Organizations and Activists


Hamsafar Trust
Founded in 1994 in Mumbai, Humasfar Trust is India's first gay-identified NGO. Its primary focus is AIDS education and condom distribution.

National AIDS Control Organization
This is the site of the National Aids Control Organization which falls under the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare of the Government of India.

Samvedna, meaning "sympathy" in Hindi, works in the red light districts of Mumbai, providing basic legal aid and medical care to sex workers and their children. Samvedna also provides educational programs and support to the children of sex workers, attempting to break the cycle of exploitation.

Samvedna
Pratima Joshi, Secretary
42/46- 13 Murgiwala Chawl
12th Lane, Kamathispura
Mumbai 00 008
Email: pratimakadam@hotmail.com

'I am a muck-raker'
Ruchira Gupta is an Indian-Candian filmmaker who documents the lives of Nepali girls living as prostitutes in Bombay.
This article by Rashmi Saksena in The Week reports on Gupta's groundbreaking work.

South Indian AIDS Action Programme
The South Indian AIDS Action Programme is a non-profit organization dealing with prevention and treatment of the disease, as well as counseling for people who are HIV positive in Chennai.

Samuha
Samuha, meaning "a collection of people" in Hindi, is an organization that works with disabled and HIV positive people in Karnataka through intervention centers.